Changes in Length—Tension and Compression: Elastic Modulus

A change in length[latex]\boldsymbol{\Delta{L}}[/latex]is produced when a force is applied to a wire or rod parallel to its length[latex]\boldsymbol{L_0},[/latex]either stretching it (a tension) or compressing it. (See Figure 3.)

Experiments have shown that the change in length ([latex]\boldsymbol{\Delta{L}}[/latex]) depends on only a few variables. As already noted,[latex]\boldsymbol{\Delta{L}}[/latex]is proportional to the force[latex]\boldsymbol{F}[/latex]and depends on the substance from which the object is made. Additionally, the change in length is proportional to the original length[latex]\boldsymbol{L_0}[/latex]and inversely proportional to the cross-sectional area of the wire or rod. For example, a long guitar string will stretch more than a short one, and a thick string will stretch less than a thin one. We can combine all these factors into one equation for[latex]\boldsymbol{\Delta{L}}:[/latex]

where[latex]\boldsymbol{\Delta{L}}[/latex]is the change in length,[latex]\boldsymbol{F}[/latex]the applied force,[latex]\boldsymbol{Y}[/latex]is a factor, called the elastic modulus or Young’s modulus, that depends on the substance,[latex]\boldsymbol{A}[/latex]is the cross-sectional area, and[latex]\boldsymbol{L_0}[/latex]is the original length. Table 3 lists values of[latex]\boldsymbol{Y}[/latex]for several materials—those with a large[latex]\boldsymbol{Y}[/latex]are said to have a large tensile stiffness because they deform less for a given tension or compression.

0.7   0.9   4.5   25   2.2

Young’s moduli are not listed for liquids and gases in Table 3 because they cannot be stretched or compressed in only one direction. Note that there is an assumption that the object does not accelerate, so that there are actually two applied forces of magnitude[latex]\boldsymbol{F}[/latex]acting in opposite directions. For example, the strings in Figure 3 are being pulled down by a force of magnitude[latex]\boldsymbol{w}[/latex]and held up by the ceiling, which also exerts a force of magnitude[latex]\boldsymbol{w}.[/latex]

Bones, on the whole, do not fracture due to tension or compression. Rather they generally fracture due to sideways impact or bending, resulting in the bone shearing or snapping. The behavior of bones under tension and compression is important because it determines the load the bones can carry. Bones are classified as weight-bearing structures such as columns in buildings and trees. Weight-bearing structures have special features; columns in building have steel-reinforcing rods while trees and bones are fibrous. The bones in different parts of the body serve different structural functions and are prone to different stresses. Thus the bone in the top of the femur is arranged in thin sheets separated by marrow while in other places the bones can be cylindrical and filled with marrow or just solid. Overweight people have a tendency toward bone damage due to sustained compressions in bone joints and tendons.

Another biological example of Hooke’s law occurs in tendons. Functionally, the tendon (the tissue connecting muscle to bone) must stretch easily at first when a force is applied, but offer a much greater restoring force for a greater strain. Figure 5 shows a stress-strain relationship for a human tendon. Some tendons have a high collagen content so there is relatively little strain, or length change; others, like support tendons (as in the leg) can change length up to 10%. Note that this stress-strain curve is nonlinear, since the slope of the line changes in different regions. In the first part of the stretch called the toe region, the fibers in the tendon begin to align in the direction of the stress—this is called uncrimping. In the linear region, the fibrils will be stretched, and in the failure region individual fibers begin to break. A simple model of this relationship can be illustrated by springs in parallel: different springs are activated at different lengths of stretch. Examples of this are given in the problems at end of this chapter. Ligaments (tissue connecting bone to bone) behave in a similar way.

Unlike bones and tendons, which need to be strong as well as elastic, the arteries and lungs need to be very stretchable. The elastic properties of the arteries are essential for blood flow. The pressure in the arteries increases and arterial walls stretch when the blood is pumped out of the heart. When the aortic valve shuts, the pressure in the arteries drops and the arterial walls relax to maintain the blood flow. When you feel your pulse, you are feeling exactly this—the elastic behavior of the arteries as the blood gushes through with each pump of the heart. If the arteries were rigid, you would not feel a pulse. The heart is also an organ with special elastic properties. The lungs expand with muscular effort when we breathe in but relax freely and elastically when we breathe out. Our skins are particularly elastic, especially for the young. A young person can go from 100 kg to 60 kg with no visible sag in their skins. The elasticity of all organs reduces with age. Gradual physiological aging through reduction in elasticity starts in the early 20s.

The equation for change in length is traditionally rearranged and written in the following form:

The ratio of force to area,[latex]\boldsymbol{\frac{F}{A}},[/latex]is defined as stress (measured in[latex]\boldsymbol{\textbf{N/m}^2}[/latex]), and the ratio of the change in length to length,[latex]\boldsymbol{\frac{\Delta{L}}{L_0}},[/latex]is defined as strain (a unitless quantity). In other words,

In this form, the equation is analogous to Hooke’s law, with stress analogous to force and strain analogous to deformation. If we again rearrange this equation to the form

we see that it is the same as Hooke’s law with a proportionality constant

This general idea—that force and the deformation it causes are proportional for small deformations—applies to changes in length, sideways bending, and changes in volume.

Sideways Stress: Shear Modulus

Figure 6 illustrates what is meant by a sideways stress or a shearing force. Here the deformation is called[latex]\boldsymbol{\Delta{x}}[/latex]and it is perpendicular to[latex]\boldsymbol{L_0},[/latex]rather than parallel as with tension and compression. Shear deformation behaves similarly to tension and compression and can be described with similar equations. The expression for shear deformation is

where[latex]\boldsymbol{S}[/latex]is the shear modulus (see Table 3) and[latex]\boldsymbol{F}[/latex]is the force applied perpendicular to[latex]\boldsymbol{L_0}[/latex]and parallel to the cross-sectional area[latex]\boldsymbol{A}.[/latex]Again, to keep the object from accelerating, there are actually two equal and opposite forces[latex]\boldsymbol{F}[/latex]applied across opposite faces, as illustrated in Figure 6. The equation is logical—for example, it is easier to bend a long thin pencil (small[latex]\boldsymbol{A}[/latex]) than a short thick one, and both are more easily bent than similar steel rods (large[latex]\boldsymbol{S}[/latex]).

Examination of the shear moduli in Table 3 reveals some telling patterns. For example, shear moduli are less than Young’s moduli for most materials. Bone is a remarkable exception. Its shear modulus is not only greater than its Young’s modulus, but it is as large as that of steel. This is why bones are so rigid.

The spinal column (consisting of 26 vertebral segments separated by discs) provides the main support for the head and upper part of the body. The spinal column has normal curvature for stability, but this curvature can be increased, leading to increased shearing forces on the lower vertebrae. Discs are better at withstanding compressional forces than shear forces. Because the spine is not vertical, the weight of the upper body exerts some of both. Pregnant women and people that are overweight (with large abdomens) need to move their shoulders back to maintain balance, thereby increasing the curvature in their spine and so increasing the shear component of the stress. An increased angle due to more curvature increases the shear forces along the plane. These higher shear forces increase the risk of back injury through ruptured discs. The lumbosacral disc (the wedge shaped disc below the last vertebrae) is particularly at risk because of its location.

The shear moduli for concrete and brick are very small; they are too highly variable to be listed. Concrete used in buildings can withstand compression, as in pillars and arches, but is very poor against shear, as might be encountered in heavily loaded floors or during earthquakes. Modern structures were made possible by the use of steel and steel-reinforced concrete. Almost by definition, liquids and gases have shear moduli near zero, because they flow in response to shearing forces.

Example 3: Calculating Force Required to Deform: That Nail Does Not Bend Much Under a Load

Find the mass of the picture hanging from a steel nail as shown in Figure 7, given that the nail bends only[latex]\boldsymbol{1.80\:\mu\textbf{m}}.[/latex](Assume the shear modulus is known to two significant figures.)

Strategy

The force[latex]\boldsymbol{F}[/latex]on the nail (neglecting the nail’s own weight) is the weight of the picture[latex]\boldsymbol{w}.[/latex]If we can find[latex]\boldsymbol{w},[/latex]then the mass of the picture is just[latex]\boldsymbol{wg}.[/latex]The equation[latex]\boldsymbol{\Delta{x}=\frac{1}{S}\frac{F}{A}L_0}[/latex]can be solved for[latex]\boldsymbol{F}.[/latex]

Solution

Solving the equation[latex]\boldsymbol{\Delta{x}=\frac{1}{S}\frac{F}{A}L_0}[/latex]for[latex]\boldsymbol{F},[/latex]we see that all other quantities can be found:

[latex]\boldsymbol{F\:=}[/latex][latex]\boldsymbol{\frac{SA}{L_0}}[/latex][latex]\boldsymbol{\Delta{x}}.[/latex]

S is found in Table 3 and is[latex]\boldsymbol{S=80\times10^9\textbf{ N/m}^2}.[/latex]The radius[latex]\boldsymbol{r}[/latex]is 0.750 mm (as seen in the figure), so the cross-sectional area is

[latex]\boldsymbol{A=\pi{r}^2=1.77\times10^{-6}\textbf{ m}^2}.[/latex]

The value for[latex]\boldsymbol{L_0}[/latex]is also shown in the figure. Thus,

[latex]\boldsymbol{F\:=}[/latex][latex]\boldsymbol{\frac{(80\times10^9\textbf{ N/m}^2)(1.77\times10^{-6}\textbf{ m}^2)}{(5.00\times10^{-3}\textbf{ m})}(1.80\times10^{-6}\textbf{ m})}[/latex][latex]\boldsymbol{=\:51\textbf{ N}}.[/latex]

This 51 N force is the weight[latex]\boldsymbol{w}[/latex]of the picture, so the picture’s mass is

[latex]\boldsymbol{m\:=}[/latex][latex]\boldsymbol{\frac{w}{g}}[/latex][latex]\boldsymbol{=}[/latex][latex]\boldsymbol{\frac{F}{g}}[/latex][latex]\boldsymbol{=\:5.2\textbf{ kg}}.[/latex]

Discussion

This is a fairly massive picture, and it is impressive that the nail flexes only[latex]\boldsymbol{1.80 \:\mu\textbf{m}}[/latex]—an amount undetectable to the unaided eye.

Changes in Volume: Bulk Modulus

An object will be compressed in all directions if inward forces are applied evenly on all its surfaces as in Figure 8. It is relatively easy to compress gases and extremely difficult to compress liquids and solids. For example, air in a wine bottle is compressed when it is corked. But if you try corking a brim-full bottle, you cannot compress the wine—some must be removed if the cork is to be inserted. The reason for these different compressibilities is that atoms and molecules are separated by large empty spaces in gases but packed close together in liquids and solids. To compress a gas, you must force its atoms and molecules closer together. To compress liquids and solids, you must actually compress their atoms and molecules, and very strong electromagnetic forces in them oppose this compression.

We can describe the compression or volume deformation of an object with an equation. First, we note that a force “applied evenly” is defined to have the same stress, or ratio of force to area[latex]\boldsymbol{\frac{F}{A}}[/latex]on all surfaces. The deformation produced is a change in volume[latex]\boldsymbol{\Delta{V}},[/latex]which is found to behave very similarly to the shear, tension, and compression previously discussed. (This is not surprising, since a compression of the entire object is equivalent to compressing each of its three dimensions.) The relationship of the change in volume to other physical quantities is given by

where[latex]\boldsymbol{B}[/latex]is the bulk modulus (see Table 3),[latex]\boldsymbol{V_0}[/latex]is the original volume, and[latex]\boldsymbol{\frac{F}{A}}[/latex]is the force per unit area applied uniformly inward on all surfaces. Note that no bulk moduli are given for gases.

What are some examples of bulk compression of solids and liquids? One practical example is the manufacture of industrial-grade diamonds by compressing carbon with an extremely large force per unit area. The carbon atoms rearrange their crystalline structure into the more tightly packed pattern of diamonds. In nature, a similar process occurs deep underground, where extremely large forces result from the weight of overlying material. Another natural source of large compressive forces is the pressure created by the weight of water, especially in deep parts of the oceans. Water exerts an inward force on all surfaces of a submerged object, and even on the water itself. At great depths, water is measurably compressed, as the following example illustrates.

Conversely, very large forces are created by liquids and solids when they try to expand but are constrained from doing so—which is equivalent to compressing them to less than their normal volume. This often occurs when a contained material warms up, since most materials expand when their temperature increases. If the materials are tightly constrained, they deform or break their container. Another very common example occurs when water freezes. Water, unlike most materials, expands when it freezes, and it can easily fracture a boulder, rupture a biological cell, or crack an engine block that gets in its way.

Other types of deformations, such as torsion or twisting, behave analogously to the tension, shear, and bulk deformations considered here.